SunServer vs Windows Server

Clovertech Forums Read Only Archives Cloverleaf Operating Systems SunServer vs Windows Server

  • Creator
    Topic
  • #47807
    Serjik Jookar
    Participant

      We are in process of replacing Sun Enterprise E3500 server and would like to know if Windows server would do the job for our multi site production environment.

      Would be appreciated if there’s anybody wants to share the advantages or disadvantages of running QDXi 5.3.1 on Windows environment.

      Thanks,

    Viewing 3 reply threads
    • Author
      Replies
      • #56761
        Terry Kellum
        Participant

          We started out on Windows, and quickly moved off onto Linux.

          We found it intolerable when we would get a Vista -921 problem and had to bounce the box to get the site back up.  We had problems with file locking, especially on large files, and the scripting and scheduling utilities on Windows are abysmal.  We now use Linux and use Samba to access all the points of interest in the engine.  While some may put up with Cloverleaf on Windows, we found that the better option in our case was Linux.

        • #56762
          Serjik Jookar
          Participant

            What causes Vista -921 error? Does Quovadx has any recommendations or any fixes for that problem? What kind of server (hardware, processor, memory, etc) you used to run Windows? May be a high end Windows server with more processing power be a solution for the problems you experienced with Windows. (Just a thought)

            Thanks you so much for sharing your experience with Windows.

            Serjik

          • #56763
            Terry Kellum
            Participant

              The Vista -921 error is where you get a user that has a lock on the database.  dbVista has a LMCLEAR command that works on Unix/Linux to clear out the bad user, but this utility does not always work on Windows. (Does not Usually work on Windows.)  Every time that I got that error, I had to bounce the box to get my site back.

               Windows also appears to have unsophisticated locking behavior.  Can you look at a smat file on a running process?  In Windows you can’t because there is a lock on the file.  In Linux, you can look at the file all you want without an error unless you try to save to the file. (I’ve never tried doing that… T’would be like crossing the streams…..)

               We also observed that Windows did not handle large smat files very well.  Try this:  Work up a 200MB smat file and then shut down the process.  See how long it takes for the file to be readible. (Unlocked)  Try it several more times.  When you see consistent behavior, please call the Associated Press, or the Alexis de Torqueville institute.  Try cycling large smat files.

               We are configured with Samba shares on our SMAT dirs.  I can look at anything and when we cycle the files, it happens now.

               While I’m a Linux fan, I don’t consider myself to be rabid.  Windows makes a great desktop system,  but I don’t think that it should be running mission-critical systems.  That’s my two cents, and you get what you pay for….

            • #56764
              Serjik Jookar
              Participant

                Terry,

                Thanks for your advise and sharing your experience.

                Serjik

            Viewing 3 reply threads
            • The forum ‘Operating Systems’ is closed to new topics and replies.